Horsehide Humble Pie

Cicotte Auto

Those of us who have a lifetime passion for the game of baseball have a tendency to think we’re more knowledgeable about the game than the next guy. And, after penning 400+ columns on the subject, I’m no exception to the rule.


Well, I’m here to tell you that it is time for your scribe to eat some humble pie…and the main ingredient will be horsehide! In other words, as you’ve probably already guessed, there’s a lot about baseball I don’t know.


Being from the first class of Baby Boomers, my knowledge of post World War II baseball is pretty extensive. There aren’t many players from that era who have a name that isn’t familiar to me. Along with the recognition, there are hundreds of small stories that are still clinging to my gray matter…Eddie Waitkus was the real Roy Hobbs, Tony Conigliaro got beaned by Jack Hamilton, Mike Kekich & Fritz Peterson swapped wives during Spring Training…and so many more. Yet, even I’m taken by surprise on occasion… just the other day, a customer at the baseball card shop stumped me with, “What Yankee player wore #3 after Babe Ruth and #7 before Mickey Mantle?”


As for the first half-century of baseball, most fans know the famous – and infamous – stars of the era…Babe Ruth, Ty Cobb, Shoeless Joe Jackson, Cy Young, Christy Mathewson and the like. The real question is, however, which great stars of the time have names that are essentially unrecognizable to even avid baseball fans? That question has come home to roost for your humble blogger, as I’ve been asked to curate and market a collection of over 1,000 sports autographs for the estate of a long-time sports fan. In a November visit, I detailed the project, but here’s the short summary…


In the late 1940’s, a young sports fan decided to build an autograph collection. The process was simple, but effective, as he would send a self-addressed post card in an envelope with a note to the player (or team) asking them to sign the postcard and mail it back. In the days before eBay, auction houses and the marketing of autographs, athletes were happy to fill the request. The youngster would cut out the signature portion of the returned post card and tape it an album along with pictures and articles of the players. As he grew up, the collection began to include many signatures acquired in person at games and other events. The end result was a collection that included thousands of autographs from ballplayers of multiple generations.


Almost 200 autographs have been chosen so far and they have been (or will be) authenticated by PSA, a third party company that specializes in sports memorabilia. Here are some of the players included up to this point. A few of the names might be familiar, but do you really know their story?


> Zack Wheat – An OF for the Brooklyn Dodgers, he played from 1909-1927 and had 2,884 Hits with a lifetime BA of .317. Inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1959.


> Paul Waner – The career of “Big Poison” stretched from 1926-1945 and he hit .333 with 3,152 Hits…#19 on the all-time list. Hall of Fame entry was in 1952.


> Eddie Cicotte – If you have seen “Eight Men Out”, you may know that he was the star Pitcher of the 1919 White Sox and one of the players who conspired to throw the World Series.


> Harry Heilman – This Tiger OF had a lifetime BA of .342 (12th all-time) and played from 1914-1932. Went into Cooperstown in 1952.


> Sam Crawford – “Wahoo” Sam made his debut in 1899 and played through 1917. He has the most Triples (309) in major league history. Voted into the HOF in 1957.


> Chief Bender – Pitched from 1903-1917 and won 212 games. The nickname came from his Native American heritage and he gained HOF induction in 1953.


> Jim Bottomley – A 16-year career (1922-1937) as a 1B produced a .310 lifetime BA. Won the NL MVP in 1927 and his HOF induction was in 1974.


> Monty Stratton – A Pitcher for the White Sox from 1934-1938, he lost his leg due to a hunting accident prior to the 1939 season. Worked with the team for the next two years as a Coach and batting practice pitcher (using a prosthetic leg). He actually pitched in the minor leagues after World War II and was immortalized in the 1949 film “The Stratton Story” in which he was portrayed by Jimmy Stewart.


> Earle Combs – Another Hall of Famer (1970), he was the CF for the Yankee dynasty of the 1920’s.


> William “Baby Doll” Jacobson – An AL OF from 1915-1927, his lifetime BA was .311. While in the minor leagues at Mobile in 1912, he was the lead-off hitter in the first game of the season. The band played “Oh, you beautiful doll” as he walked to the plate and he hit a Home Run on the first pitch…the nickname stuck.


> Ed Walsh – A dominating Pitcher from 1904-1917, he has the lowest lifetime ERA in baseball history at 1.82. In 1908, he won 40 games and pitched 464 innings. Joined the HOF in 1946.


> J. Franklin Baker – This one had me stumped for a while. Turns out it is the Frank Baker who became known as “Home Run Baker”. Played in the “dead ball era” starting in 1908 and led the AL in HR’s for three consecutive seasons (1911-1913). His leading totals were 11, 10 & 12. HOF entry was in 1955.


> Hugh Duffy – A productive OF from 1888-1906, he had a lifetime BA of .326 and also managed for eight seasons. Inducted into Cooperstown in 1945.


> Kid Nichols – Started his career with the Boston Beaneaters in 1890 and ended up winning 362 games. In the 1890’s, he won 30 or more games in seven separate seasons. 1949 was the year of his entry into the HOF.


This project has taught me a lot…how about you?


Oh, the Yankee player who is the answer to the Ruth/Mantle question is Cliff Mapes. In 1948, he wore #3 but Babe Ruth passed away that year and the Yankees retired the number. He wore #7 for the next 2 1/2 seasons, but Mantle (who originally wore #6) took the number when Mapes was traded in 1951.





Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s